How do you know if your team has gotten better? I mean overall, not just in terms of one thing. For example, Arsenal take more shots this year than last: 15.4 shots per game this season, 13.8 last season, so, are Arsenal better?
Maybe.
The most common way that people judge improvement is by position in the table at the end of the season. This is the fairest assessment of the club because the table very rarely lies. In that case, Arsenal are currently in third place, level on points with Man City but below them on goal difference. Arsenal finished 4th last season and so, if Arsenal finish the season in their current position (or higher since Man City has a game in hand), they will have shown some improvement in terms of the League table.
League table position is the most accurate measure because the League is a round-robin tournament: every team plays every other team, home and away. I’m not trying to condescend here, because I’m sure that you already know how the League works, but rather I’m explaining this because sometimes stats folks like to abstract a team’s single season stats and compare them to another season in order to draw a conclusion about whether the team in question is performing better.
For example, last season Arsenal averaged 2.08 points per game and this season Arsenal are earning just 2.03 points per game. That means last season Arsenal were a better team, right? Wrong. In the context of this season, with 6-7 teams vying for a top 4 finish, 2.03 points per game is the second best PPG rate in the League. In the context of last season, with two teams streets ahead of everyone else, scoring 100+ goals, 2.08 PPG was 4th best.
I have a theory that fan perception of improvement comes largely from a team’s record against other top clubs. You probably didn’t know this but for the last two seasons running, Arsenal have been nearly perfect against bottom half teams. Arsenal have only lost 1 match in the 37 times they have played against bottom 10 opposition in the last two seasons. Arsenal only even have 4 draws in those matches as well. That means Arsenal have won 32/37 matches against the bottom 10 teams in the League over the last two seasons. That record is unrivaled by any other club in England. Against the same opposition, Chelsea have lost 4 and drawn 6 in the last two seasons.
But against the top teams, and especially the top 7 teams, Arsenal’s record falls apart pretty quickly. Last season, against the top 7 teams, Arsenal conceded 23 goals in 12 matches. Worse, they conceded 18 goals in the 6 matches against the other top four teams. That season, Arsenal conceded 41 goals all total, so the 18 that they gave up to their top four rivals comprised 44% of the season total. It’s no wonder they only won 1 match in the top-four mini League:
This season there have been green shoots of improvement but nothing like a whole Himalayan Blackberry bush.
Against top 4 opposition Arsenal went from conceding 3 goals a game to just 1. I’ll take that as a start! You’ll note that there isn’t much difference so far in the win/draw/loss column, but if Arsenal beat Manchester United they will leap up the mini-League table into second place. Which, while it would be an improvement, it’s nothing quite like the dominance of Chelsea, who haven’t lost to a top four rival in two years.
Against top 7 teams, things don’t get much better for Arsenal. Last season, Arsenal were terrible, though could take comfort from the fact that we were slightly less terrible than Tottenham and Man U. But still W2 D4 L5 is a pretty shocking record:
This season, Arsenal are slightly better in terms of PPG, but in the same place in terms of top 7 table position. Essentially, The Gunners have won 1 more match this season (Man City) against top 7 teams:
I think the one massive improvement this season is that Arsenal don’t have a -13 goal difference against these teams, like they did last season. That might not seem like an important fact but the way Arsenal were totally owned by Chelsea, Man U, Liverpool, and City certainly impacted the mental state of the team, hurt our League standing, and ultimately killed any chance of winning the League.
As an aside, note that Arsenal’s only remaining top 7 opponent is Man U. Man U is going to be a tough match for Arsenal because they have done a 180 turn on their performances against top teams from last season to this. I think this record against top teams is the major reason why van Gaal is seen as an improvement over Moyes. If Wenger can get three points against United it will qualify as an improvement this season. And if he can continue to get some improvement against top teams next season, while continuing Arsenal’s amazing dominance over bottom 10 teams, Arsenal will win the League.
Defensively, Arsenal haven’t improved much if any at all. Last season, Arsenal conceded 1.08 goals per game and this season they are conceding 0.97. In the context of the average number of goals conceded per game in the Premier League last season (1.38) and this season (1.32) the difference between our goals allowed record last season versus this season is a mere 0.04 per game or 1.52 fewer goals over a 38 game season. It’s more accurate to say that the Premier League has seen a dip in scoring this season than to say that Arsenal have gotten better at defending. And remember, Arsenal have been on a defensive tear since January, conceding just 9 goals in 14 matches. If they continue that run of defending, perhaps we can say that they have gotten better defensively but so far? No.
And finally, if we want to look at Arsenal’s goal scoring prowess, again, I think we need to look at that in the League context. On average last season, Premier League teams scored 1.38 goals per game. This season, Premier League teams are scoring 1.32 goals per game. Last season, Arsenal scored 1.79 goals per game, putting them +0.41 goals per game over the League average. This season, Arsenal have scored 1.91 goals per game which makes them +0.59 goals per game over the League average. That means Arsenal have improved 0.18 goals per game in the context of the League, which while it might not seem like much is the equivalent of almost 7 goals a season improvement (0.18*38).
Overall, it looks like Arsenal are improving but in increments rather than leaps and bounds that some might want you to believe. But at least there is improvement!
@7amkickoff
No comments:
Write comments